SNL’s unfunny, racist White Christmas sketch tops off a year of embarrassing white pop culture

Paul Rudd dressed as a grandmother wielding a gun in SNL's White Christmas sketch

Saturday Night Live is really running with their jokes about how they’re aware of the criticism that their cast is super white and male. They think it’s hilarious and edgy to joke about that while not actually recruiting women of color to join the cast. Their latest not remotely funny bit of hipster racism came this weekend (after an opening monologue that featured the white guys from Anchorman 2 and the almost all white guys from One Direction. It was really white and dudely) with this White Christmas sketch. Warning: it’s racist.

(I apologize I haven’t found a transcript for this terrible sketch yet. One should appear at this site soon.)

Oh that’s so clever. A bunch of white people making fun of Tyler Perry movies, the most stereotype-laden part of Black culture they have access to. These movies are critiqued within the Black community, but it’s very different for a Black artist to work with stereotypes or for a Black audience to critique that than for a bunch of white folks who have been criticized for not hiring people of color to use Tyler Perry as an excuse to make race jokes. Lazy jokes, too – as simple as white women talking about how men are dogs who will leave you for a white girl and a grandmother wielding a gun. Jokes that are supposedly clever because everyone’s aware they’re racist. This is backed up by a few fake quotes from Black publications about how offensive it all is:

“Can’t we have anything?”

“The Macklemore of movies.”

See, everyone’s in on it.

There’s way more to Black cinema than Tyler Perry, and while this wasn’t the year of the Black movie reducing Black cinema to his work does feel particularly offensive when films like Fruitvale Station and Twelve Years a Slave are in theaters.

Also I’m a big fan of drag, but what Paul Rudd’s doing here is not drag. This is a man in a dress mocking drag and specifically Black drag. I’d probably be more focused on how offensive this is if it wasn’t so embarrassingly unfunny.

When did “It’s funny because we know it’s racist” become so damn mainstream? And what is with the nonstop racist cultural appropriation? Why are white pop stars and comedians not pausing for a second to realize how ridiculous this all is? Awareness of racism does not give you a pass to be racist. We are not in a post-racial world where white people can say racist things and it’s not racist. Voting for Barack Obama did not give you a pass to be racist and have it magically turn into not-racism.

The constant assault of casual pop culture racism needs to stop. I would love it if all the problematic white pop stars and white comedy hipster bros just took a seat for 2014. Just spend the year in the corner thinking about what you’ve done. You’ve had an embarrassing year.

Jos Truitt Jos Truitt hasn’t watched SNL in a while.

and tagged , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink. Both comments and trackbacks are currently closed.


  1. Posted December 9, 2013 at 3:05 pm | Permalink

    Wow. I saw the joke there as being on white people for appropriating everything.

    • Posted December 11, 2013 at 7:17 pm | Permalink

      You’re right, Josh, that was absolutely the joke and it seems everyone else got it except the person who wrote this article, smh.

    • Posted December 11, 2013 at 10:35 pm | Permalink

      Vanishing is not funny. Laughing at it is diabolical.

  2. Posted December 11, 2013 at 10:34 pm | Permalink

    All well and good, but where would they be had not Tyler Perry shown them the way. We ARE our own worst enemies.

Feministing In Your Inbox

Sign up for our Newsletter to stay in touch with Feministing
and receive regular updates and exclusive content.

172 queries. 0.758 seconds