Feministing


Warning: Illegal string offset 'output_key' in /home5/feminist/public_html/wp-includes/nav-menu.php on line 604

Warning: Illegal string offset 'output_key' in /home5/feminist/public_html/wp-includes/nav-menu.php on line 604

Warning: Illegal string offset 'output_key' in /home5/feminist/public_html/wp-includes/nav-menu.php on line 604

Warning: Illegal string offset 'output_key' in /home5/feminist/public_html/wp-includes/nav-menu.php on line 604

Warning: Illegal string offset 'output_key' in /home5/feminist/public_html/wp-includes/nav-menu.php on line 604

Warning: Illegal string offset 'output_key' in /home5/feminist/public_html/wp-includes/nav-menu.php on line 604

Warning: Illegal string offset 'output_key' in /home5/feminist/public_html/wp-includes/nav-menu.php on line 604
  • Home
  • Support Us
  • Our Store
  • About
  • FAQs
  • Speaking Tour
  • Community

Search

We need your help!

Feministing is a labor of love and all our staff has other full-time jobs to support their work on the site. Your donation is much appreciated, and much needed.

Donate Now

Get Our Newsletter

Twitter Facebook Google+ Email RSS
© 2025 Feministing
  • Feministing

Search


Warning: Illegal string offset 'output_key' in /home5/feminist/public_html/wp-includes/nav-menu.php on line 604

Warning: Illegal string offset 'output_key' in /home5/feminist/public_html/wp-includes/nav-menu.php on line 604

Warning: Illegal string offset 'output_key' in /home5/feminist/public_html/wp-includes/nav-menu.php on line 604

Warning: Illegal string offset 'output_key' in /home5/feminist/public_html/wp-includes/nav-menu.php on line 604

Warning: Illegal string offset 'output_key' in /home5/feminist/public_html/wp-includes/nav-menu.php on line 604

Warning: Illegal string offset 'output_key' in /home5/feminist/public_html/wp-includes/nav-menu.php on line 604

Warning: Illegal string offset 'output_key' in /home5/feminist/public_html/wp-includes/nav-menu.php on line 604

Warning: Illegal string offset 'output_key' in /home5/feminist/public_html/wp-includes/nav-menu.php on line 604
  • Support Us
    • Support Feministing
    • Our Store
  • About
    • About Feministing
    • FAQs
    • Speaking Tour
  • Community
  • Feministing

By Syreeta McFadden • @reetamac • 12 years ago

VIDA’s 2012 Count shows the literary gender byline gap isn’t improving

I’m off to Boston for the annual Association of Writing Programs (AWP) Conference this week, where +/- 10k writers, editors, agents, publishers descend on the city and nerd out over craft, and geek out and build friendships with their favorite writers and editors. I anticipate a good piece of the talk around the conference will center around Monday’s release of VIDA’s 2012 Count report, which scrutinizes thought leader publication’s ratio of women writers and reviewers, as well as reviews of books written by women. Since 2010, VIDA (Women In Literary Arts) has done the good and dirty work of quantifying the void in women’s representation in publishing. This year’s report shows a backslide.

The biggest takeaway from the 2012 report is that the thought leader publications–like the New Yorker, The Atlantic, Harpers, among others–have barely made any gains in publishing a proportionate number of work by women compared to work by men. VIDA’s Amy King notes further:

While it would be incredibly easy to begin by lambasting national publications like Harpers, The Paris Review, The New Republic, New York Review Of Books, Times Literary Supplement, The New Republic and The Nation for their gross (& indecent) neglect of female writers’ work, I fear the attention we’ve already given them has either motivated their editors to disdain the mirrors we’ve held up to further neglect or encouraged them to actively turn those mirrors into funhouse parodies at costs to women writers as yet untallied. Reason hasn’t worked. The devolution among their ranks screams itself increasingly red in the VIDA comparative charts. At this point, the publications with the “most men” simply do not win.

I’m of multiple minds here about the subtext in these numbers. Individually, as a reader of these publications, I’ve seen scattered progress–some gems of book reviews from new writers, great criticism and journalism by women and people of color. VIDA’s comparison chart most notably reflects this observation; 2011 shows modest gains. Yet, Alyssa Rosenberg offered a keen insight to these numbers that I wondered out loud to myself in considering the backslide:

My guess would be that the problem is less malign, but more insidious. I’d be willing to bet that every editor of every publication on this list is, in theory at least, committed to the principals of gender equity. But I’d also be comfortable laying money on the idea that they’re equally convinced that their subconscious biases, reliance on familiar authors, and processes to sort submissions and identify new contributors are sound and don’t in any way work to produce byline inequality. They’re probably uncomfortable with the idea of quotas and target numbers, in part because they want to have faith in their own processes. In other words, they can acknowledge a problem without thinking that it’s their problem. And making that connection is what’s important.

Literary stalwarts like Tin House and The Boston Review are doing more and better. In the case of Tin House, the editorial staff has publicly declared that they’re making a conscious effort to publish more women authors. (To Alyssa’s point, the editor, Rob Spillman, has made the connection that the underrepresentation of women voices in his magazine is his problem to correct.) Yet, I wonder too, if we’re not making ourselves visible or known. As one of the editors of a literary startup, men outnumber women submitters by 3 to 1. (I should also note that women are submitting work in greater numbers to our literary magazine in the past year). I don’t believe it’s self sabotage, but I bet we could lean in, you know (no shade, I actually plan to *read* her book first). However, I wonder if perhaps it’s more than just relying on gender imbalanced editorial staff, accustomed to using writers they know or feel comfortable with, to do the good work of capturing new talent. Or if women contributors are steered, isolated toward writing “women-themed” content.

Three years of counting an imbalance we’ve quietly observed for years isn’t enough time to manifest systematic change within the publishing world. But it’s a critical tool in informing the conversation about representation in our culture–the voices we celebrate, the witnesses to our histories, and the legacies we’ll leave behind.

Syreeta McFadden

SYREETA MCFADDEN is a Brooklyn based writer, photographer and adjunct professor of English. Her writing has appeared in the New York Times, The Guardian, BuzzFeed, The Huffington Post, Religion Dispatches and Storyscape Journal. She is the managing editor of the online literary magazine, Union Station, and a co-curator of Poets in Unexpected Places. You can follow her on Twitter @reetamac.

Syreeta McFadden is a contributing opinion writer for The Guardian US and an editor of Union Station Magazine.

Read more about Syreeta
Syreeta McFadden Syreeta McFadden

We need your help!

Feministing is a labor of love and all our staff have other full-time jobs to support their work on the site. Your donation is much appreciated, and much needed.

Donate Now

Join the Conversation

Related Content

  • As Long as Our Policies Toward Families Suck, Women Will Bear The Domestic Burden

    By Reina Gattuso

  • Chart of the Day: Women created 37 percent of the news last year

    By Maya Dusenbery

  • Latest VIDA count of gender gap in the literary world counts women of color

    By Maya Dusenbery

enjoli-woman
By Reina Gattuso • @reinagattuso • 8 years ago

As Long as Our Policies Toward Families Suck, Women Will Bear The Domestic Burden

My mom came of age as a feminist in the late 70s, and man, did it show.

She didn’t believe in women taking a man’s name upon marriage. She gifted my two sisters and I a copy of Our Bodies, Ourselves for Christmas when I was fourteen (and I’ve been having stunning orgasms ever since, so thanks, mom!). And she believed stubbornly, resolutely, in women’s ability to have a career and a family. When she told us of the dreams she’d had as a young woman, she liked to quote this 1980 perfume commercial—she could “bring home the bacon and fry it up in the pan.”

Which is why a recent report from the Council on Contemporary Families would depress her to no end. Written up ...

My mom came of age as a feminist in the late 70s, and man, did it show.

She didn’t believe in women taking a man’s name upon marriage. She gifted my two sisters and I a copy ...

Read More
Divided 2015: The media gender gap
By Maya Dusenbery • @mayadusenbery • 9 years ago

Chart of the Day: Women created 37 percent of the news last year

The Women’s Media Center is out with their latest report on the gender gap in media — from the newsroom to the big screen. 

Overall, there’s been little progress since last year when I highlighted several charts from the report illustrating how dominated by white men the media landscape is. Yet again the report provides a wealth of depressing factoids. Such as: Last year, only 37 percent of the news was generated by a woman. Just 12 percent of movie protagonists are women. There are 7 percent fewer women in sports journalism than last year.

Check out the rest of the infographic on the gap in the news media here and the read the full report — which covers everything ...

The Women’s Media Center is out with their latest report on the gender gap in media — from the newsroom to the big screen. 

Overall, there’s been little progress since last year when I highlighted ...

Read More
VIDA count charts
By Maya Dusenbery • @mayadusenbery • 10 years ago

Latest VIDA count of gender gap in the literary world counts women of color

The fifth annual VIDA Count measuring the gender gap in the literary world is out.

This year, for the first time, an effort was made to break down the numbers by race. While they weren’t able to get a complete tally, WAM!’s Jamia Wilson notes, “This year’s attempt at counting women of color paves the way for a deeper public conversation about who has power and privilege at all levels of the literary landscape—and how that impacts whose voices are heard.”

While the overall numbers look similar to previous year’s, there’s been some small steps toward gender equality. A few publications that had vowed to make a ...

The fifth annual VIDA Count measuring the gender gap in the literary world is out.

This year, for the first time, an effort was made to break down the ...

Read More
byline gap▪gender equality▪Vida▪women in media▪Women Writers
Twitter Facebook Google+ Email RSS

Warning: Illegal string offset 'output_key' in /home5/feminist/public_html/wp-includes/nav-menu.php on line 604

Warning: Illegal string offset 'output_key' in /home5/feminist/public_html/wp-includes/nav-menu.php on line 604

Warning: Illegal string offset 'output_key' in /home5/feminist/public_html/wp-includes/nav-menu.php on line 604

Warning: Illegal string offset 'output_key' in /home5/feminist/public_html/wp-includes/nav-menu.php on line 604

Warning: Illegal string offset 'output_key' in /home5/feminist/public_html/wp-includes/nav-menu.php on line 604

Warning: Illegal string offset 'output_key' in /home5/feminist/public_html/wp-includes/nav-menu.php on line 604

Warning: Illegal string offset 'output_key' in /home5/feminist/public_html/wp-includes/nav-menu.php on line 604

Warning: Illegal string offset 'output_key' in /home5/feminist/public_html/wp-includes/nav-menu.php on line 604
  • Support Us
    • Support Feministing
    • Our Store
  • About
    • About Feministing
    • FAQs
    • Speaking Tour
  • Community

Search

We need your help!

Feministing is a labor of love and all our staff have other full-time jobs to support their work on the site. Your monthly membership will help us pay our columnists.

Become a Member

Get Our Newsletter

New posts and Feministing news delivered to your inbox weekly!

Want to write for us?

All Feministing posts are written by the site’s collective of regular columnists and editors. Though we don’t currently accept guest submissions, we have an open platform Community site to which anyone can contribute. We often promote our favorite Community posts on the main site. And Community bloggers who consistently impress us may to be invited to become regular Feministing columnists..

Our Community Site

Editors' Picks

  • I Asked the Department of Education to Fight for Black Girls. They Ignored Me.
    By fatimahfair
  • Indian Supreme Court Decriminalizes Queer Sex, and Everyone Celebrates!
    By Reina Gattuso
  • Ohio Cop Murders Donna Dalton, Sex Worker, Mother, and Friend
    By Jess Fournier
  • Drug Tests: Weapons Against the Marginalized
    By Reina Gattuso
  • It’s Long Past Time to Make Childcare Central To the Progressive Agenda
    By Sejal Singh

Meet the Crew

  • Lori AdelmanLori Adelman
    Executive Director, Partnerships
  • Maya DusenberyMaya Dusenbery
    Executive Director, Editorial
  • Dana BolgerDana Bolger
    Senior Editor
  • Juliana Britto SchwartzJuliana Britto Schwartz
    Senior Editor
  • Mahroh JahangiriMahroh Jahangiri
    Editor
  • Reina GattusoReina Gattuso
    Columnist
  • Senti SojwalSenti Sojwal
    Interviews Columnist
  • Meg SriMeg Sri
    Columnist
  • Jess FournierJess Fournier
    Columnist
  • Amanda R. MatosAmanda R. Matos
    Columnist
  • Chanelle AdamsChanelle Adams
    Books Columnist
  • Sam HuberSam Huber
    Books columnist
  • Ava KofmanAva Kofman
    Books columnist

Hot Topics

  • Reproductive Rights
  • Sexism
  • Politics
  • News
  • Activism
Twitter Facebook Google+ Email RSS
© 2025 Feministing
Share This!
Feministing
Warning: Illegal string offset 'output_key' in /home5/feminist/public_html/wp-includes/nav-menu.php on line 604

Warning: Illegal string offset 'output_key' in /home5/feminist/public_html/wp-includes/nav-menu.php on line 604

Warning: Illegal string offset 'output_key' in /home5/feminist/public_html/wp-includes/nav-menu.php on line 604

Warning: Illegal string offset 'output_key' in /home5/feminist/public_html/wp-includes/nav-menu.php on line 604

Warning: Illegal string offset 'output_key' in /home5/feminist/public_html/wp-includes/nav-menu.php on line 604

Warning: Illegal string offset 'output_key' in /home5/feminist/public_html/wp-includes/nav-menu.php on line 604

Warning: Illegal string offset 'output_key' in /home5/feminist/public_html/wp-includes/nav-menu.php on line 604

Warning: Illegal string offset 'output_key' in /home5/feminist/public_html/wp-includes/nav-menu.php on line 604
  • Support Us
    • Support Feministing
    • Our Store
  • About
    • About Feministing
    • FAQs
    • Speaking Tour
  • Community
Twitter Facebook Google+ Email RSS
© Feministing 2025