McCullen: A view from a thousand feet

Clinic escortsAbortion clinics are a dangerous place for staffers and patients. As Vicki Saporta told the Huffington Post,”[s]ince 1977, there have been 8 murders, 17 attempted murders, 42 bombings, 181 arsons, and thousands of incidents of criminal activities.” You wouldn’t know that, though, from yesterday’s Supreme Court decision McCullen v. Coakley. Maya wrote yesterday that the dangerous, disappointing McCullen struck down Massachusetts’ “buffer zone” law. Buffer zones were set up to protect people entering abortion clinics for services or work against violence and harassment — but Chief Justice Roberts, writing for the majority, elides these threats and re-imagines the anti-choice protester as a grinning granny with  some good advice. These protesters, Roberts explains, merely want to provide quiet “counseling.” And their pamphlets and one-on-one conversations are “historically . . . associated with the transmission of ideas,” as though clinic harassment was the next installment of the fucking Federalist Papers.

Saporta points out that “aggressive threats and intimidation, stalking patients from their cars to the door, and verbally and physically assaulting them is not counseling,” and, as Dr. Jane Chi tweeted, “[i]f abortion picketers were ‘plump grandmothers’ making ‘quiet conversation,’ we wouldn’t have needed buffer zones.” Yet the Court, in this decision, prioritized its abstracted vision of abortion — which exists first and foremost not as a medical service but as a topic of debate — over actual abortions.

Of course, there is nothing theoretical about abortion for one in three women and many trans men and gender queer people. Abortion isn’t a symbol. It isn’t an idea. It’s a medical procedure they chose to undergo. And the sidewalk outside the clinic isn’t a metaphor for the American abortion debate or the polarization of public opinion, but an actual sidewalk through which their actual bodies must cross in the face of actual harassment. To treat it as an abstraction is disrespectful to those who know too well the very real impacts of impeded access — and also betrays the Court’s distance from the on-the-ground dangers it now exacerbates. In McCullen we see the Justices looking down on the sidewalks of America’s clinics from a thousand feet. From this great height, every walk through the crowds looks shorter and every death threat sounds softer. It must feel very safe up there.

As Jill Fillipovic writes at Cosmopolitan, it’s unclear what the future of buffer zones will be. But the Court’s inattention to the concrete realities of American’s lived experiences of clinic harassment is a bad omen for cases that will likely come to the Justices in the next few years. TRAP laws — laws that target abortion providers in order to shut down services — may look innocuous on paper but create significant obstacles for patients by shutting down clinics and requiring additional trips. But in order to recognize these harms, the Court has to be willing to climb down from Mount Olympus and see what abortion access looks like on the ground.

Image via.

AlexandraAlexandra Brodsky is a Feministing editor, student at Yale Law School, and founding co-director of Know Your IX.

Washington, DC

Alexandra Brodsky was a senior editor at During her four years at the site, she wrote about gender violence, reproductive justice, and education equity and ran the site's book review column. She is now a Skadden Fellow at the National Women's Law Center and also serves as the Board Chair of Know Your IX, a national student-led movement to end gender violence, which she co-founded and previously co-directed. Alexandra has written for publications including the New York Times, the Atlantic, the Guardian, and the Nation, and she is the co-editor of The Feminist Utopia Project: 57 Visions of a Wildly Better Future. She has spoken about violence against women and reproductive justice at campuses across the country and on MSNBC, ABC, NBC, CBS, CNN, FOX, ESPN, and NPR.

Alexandra Brodsky was a senior editor at

Read more about Alexandra

Join the Conversation