Of course, some of you anti-choicers won’t be convinced by this evidence because it was done by scientists, which you’ll find sketchy. But just so you know, a study, commissioned by the National Collaborating Centre for Mental Health, part of the Royal College of Psychiatrists in the UK and funded by the England’s Department of Health, reviewed 44 studies from 1990-2011 on the relationship between abortion and mental health and concluded,
“The best current evidence suggests that it makes no difference to a woman’s mental health whether she chooses to have an abortion or to continue with the pregnancy.”
The study does say that women who have unwanted pregnancies have an increased risk of depression and anxiety, but choosing an abortion does not make them more at risk than having the baby. In other words the correlation is between mental stress and an unwanted pregnancy in itself, not between mental stress and abortion.
It’s also important to note, as the study does, that while women with unwanted pregnancies suffer from anxiety and depression at greater rates (1 of 3) than the general female population (11-12%), this correlation may not always be causal. The unwanted pregnancy may be responsible, the psychological symptoms may precede the unwanted pregnancy, or there may a combination of the two factors. Women with a history of mental illness or who are pressured by their partners into getting an abortion have higher rates of mental health problems following a termination. So the takeaway is that abortions don’t pose a mental health risk, but mental illness and lack of, well, choice (or feeling like you have a choice) do.
If anti-choicers actually cared about the mental health of women– which I’m not sure they do, since their interest in life seems to begin at conception but end at actual childbirth — what they (and all of us) should be concerned with is making sure women have access to contraception, education, sex-ed, healthcare and are empowered to make their own decisions, not bullied or pressured by someone else. Unsurprisingly, a spokesperson for the Society for the Protection of Unborn Children, Anthony Ozimic, rejected the study, insisting that “Women experienced feelings such as shame, guilt, grief and regret after an abortion.”
Of course to the extent that women feel shame, guilt, grief, and regret after an abortion, the anti choice movement is causing the very symptoms it claims it wants to protect women from.
* Jos and Lori have pointed out the limitations of viewing abortion as a women’s only issue. I agree but since the study did use the male/female binary, I couldn’t include sections of the population (trans, two-spirit ) who they didn’t.