Case contesting “crime against nature” law rocks my world

A lawsuit has been brought against the state of Louisiana for its nonsensical and discriminatory use of an antiquated “crime against nature” statute to arrest and prosecute sex workers.

And it is kind of rocking my world.

According to a recent press release, Women With a Vision (WWAV) has brought its campaign for repeal of Louisiana’s Solicitation of a Crime Against Nature (SCAN) statute to the steps of the federal court with the lawsuit Doe v. Jindal. Calling the SCAN statute “unconstitutional” on equal protection grounds and “cruel and unusual punishment”, the complaint names nine plaintiffs, including a grandmother, a mother of four, three transgender women, and a man, all of whom have been required to register as sex offenders from 15 years to life as a result of their convictions for the solicitation of oral sex for money.

The Center for Constitutional Rights, a Loyola University law clinic, and the bad-ass Andrea Ritchie, Esq., a police misconduct attorney, are representing the plaintiffs.

Louisiana’s statute criminalizes the solicitation of oral or anal sex for money, despite the existence of a prostitution law that covers the same conduct. While penalties for first convictions are the same for both laws, SCAN requires second and subsequent offenders to register as sex offenders from 15 years to life. In the words of one plaintiff, “It’s like the scarlet letter. I am trying to put that in my past – but it’s not gonna be in my past because it’s in my present, and it’s going to be my future for the next 13 years.”

SCAN is the only registrable crime that does not involve force or the victimization of children, yet, as you can see in the graph below, 40 percent of those on the Orleans Parish registry are registered for a SCAN conviction, making SCAN the single most frequent law under which sex offenders are registered in Orleans Parish.

Bar graph of number of people registered as sex offender by conviction type in Orleans parish. 292: SCAN, 85: Forcible rape, 75: Felony carnal knowledge, 78: Indecent behavior with juveniles

To add insult to injury, and perhaps not surprisingly, the law contributes to further discrimination by being applied inconsistently, in effect singling out poor Black women involved in street-based economies, transgender women and gay men of color. According to the WWAV press release, 80 percent of those registered solely because of a SCAN conviction are African American.

Women With a Vision has three demands for the Louisiana legislature, and I stand behind each of them:

1. Repeal the Solicitation of a Crime Against Nature Statute (SCAN).

2. Abolish Registry Requirements for Individuals Currently on the Registry Whose Only Registrable Offense is SCAN.

3. Expunge All State Records Labeling Individuals Whose Only Registrable Offense is Crime Against Nature by Solicitation as Sex Offenders.

Here’s sending support and well wishes to the bad-ass women of WWAV, as well as their awesome team of lawyers, as they do the massively important work of dismantling racist, sexist, sex-negative, and transphobic relics of a broken system.

h/t to Audacia Ray

Brooklyn, NY

Lori Adelman is a writer and advocate focusing on race, gender, and sexual and reproductive rights. In addition to serving as an Executive Director at Feministing, Lori is the Director of Global Communications at Planned Parenthood Federation of America. Lori has previously worked at the United Nations Foundation, the International Women’s Health Coalition, and Human Rights Watch, and has written for a host of print and digital properties including Rookie Magazine, The Grio, and the New York Times Magazine. She regularly appears on radio and television, and has spoken at college campuses across the U.S. about topics like the politics of black hair, transnational movement building, and the undercover feminism of Nicki Minaj. In 2014, she was named to The Root 100 list of the nation's most influential African Americans, and to the Forbes Magazine list of the "30 Under 30" successful people in media.

Lori Adelman is an Executive Director of Feministing in charge of Partnerships.

Read more about Lori

Join the Conversation