Update about “Porn in a Flash” quote.

Last week I wrote about an article run by Salon about “upskirting” and “downblousing” using a quote from John Morris at the Center for Democracy and Technology that certainly set off some alarm bells.
From my post,

Unfortunately, the debate that ensues is a question of whether or not your privacy is being violated since you are on the street and as a public place is free to be photographed with all participants or as John Morris, from the Center for Democracy & Technology, says in the article, “If you don’t want to be photographed walking the street, don’t walk down the street — it’s a public street.”

I have a friend that works at CDT and felt this was a bad characterization of the goals and values of their organization and brought it to the attention of the Director and CEO Leslie Harris, who has released this statement.

The recent Salon article, “Porn in a Flash,” contains a quote from our General Council John Morris that was taken out of context. John’s quote: “If you don’t want to be photographed walking the street, don’t walk down the street — it’s a public street,” spoke to the broader, general question of whether someone has an expectation of privacy in a public place. Placement of the quote, however, made John sound unsympathetic toward “upskirting” and “downblousing.” Of course these practices are wrong, and of course there is a difference between a snapshot on the street and this sort of invasive voyeurism.
CDT is a strong advocate of personal privacy and commends the steps states have taken to criminalize these nefarious practices. Federal privacy laws were passed before the majority of today’s portable technologies existed outside of Dick Tracy comic books. That’s why CDT is pressing Congress to rewrite the privacy laws and bring them up-to-date with today’s technology and provide the sorely needed protections missing from the law as it stands today. We fully believe that state invasion of privacy laws can, if carefully drafted, adequately address these upskirting and downblousing practices.
Leslie Harris
President & CEO
Center for Democracy & Technology

Join the Conversation